Home Search News Arts & Culture Schools Real Estate
Opinion Letters Maps Feature article History Landmarks
Archives Photos Renters Westside Village Religion Citywide
Our diversity is our strength

The Palms–Village Sun
News, opinion and features about Historic Palms,
including Westside Village
www.PalmsVillageSun.info
This site is not affiliated with any group. Opinions are those of the writers.

May 2006
THIS IS THE WESTSIDE VILLAGE PAGE
One of only two Web pages in the entire universe that give a woof about Westside Village.
WESTSIDE VILLAGE LINKS
FEATURES
SCHOOLS
MAPS
ORGANIZATIONS
Palms-Westside Village Neighborhood Watch
This NONCOMMERCIAL site is a harmless hobby of George Garrigues, who has lived in the Westside Village district of Palms for a dozen years or so. These pages have no connection with any organization.
Send him e-mail with corrections and comments
Statements by ROBERTA GOLAN SCHILLER, Candidate for Zone 1 representative (Westside Village) on the Board of the Mar Vista Community Council

An e-mail from The Palms-Village Sun requested comments from candidate Roberta Schiller about the Mar Vista takeover of the Westside Village area

Unfortunately, the candidate did not see fit to reply to the question

See below
This is an extension of a story that is also on our Front Page this month.

There has been some hassle recently over where Palms should put its boundary markers. The Outreach and Communications Committee of the Palms Neighborhood Council came up with a list that included some dubious locations, and the Council's Representative Assembly kicked the list back to the committee for further study.

On this matter the Palms Neighborhhood Council received a May 2 e-mail from Ken Alpern, who is a board member of both the Mar Vista Community Council and the Westside Village homeowners assn.

My name is Ken Alpern, and I co-chair the Mar Vista Community Council (MVCC) Urban Planning/Land Use Committee — most of you probably know me from previous meetings. 
 
I want to again congratulate the Palms Representative Assembly on the work you've done to make your new Neighborhood Council thrive, and I wish Pauline Stout the best of luck in her new role as President of the Representative Assembly.
 
I regret that my work obligations and an evening lecture prevent me from attending tomorrow night's meeting, but I'd like to mention a few issues relating to your agenda and to developments in the Palms region:
 
1) As pertains to Agenda Item #6.C.vii.:
 
I look forward to seeing "Palms" signs in the Palms region as part of a new era of economic development and neighborhood pride.
 
However, I will let the Westside Village Civic Association Board President speak for herself, but I recommend posting any new "Palms" signs out of Westside Village.  Regardless of the history of the region, there is a growing sense amongst Westside Villagers of being their own community, and hence the benefit of allowing Westside Villagers to choose to be active with either or both the MVCC and Palms NC.
 
I urge any "Palms" signs at National/Overland (National Blvd. or National Place?) to be located on the SE corner (as is currently listed on your agenda) and not the SW corner (as was previously described on the agenda listed on the Palms-Westside Village Sun website). 
 
There may have been a typo or some clerical error, but as much as I look forward to new "Palms" signs in the region, I think that the Palms NC should advocate for signs within its own boundaries.

Outreach Committee Chair Mario Bruhwiler replied on May 3:

I have examined our choice of Locations and realized that the wrong location was put into the agenda and that it is the Southeast Corner, since these signs are to be at the Entry Points into Palms.   We want to have all of our residential stakeholders to know they have live in the Palms area and visitors or passers-by to know they are in the Palms area.

As chair of the PNC Community Outreach and Communication Committee, I would like to extend my own appreciation for the civil e-mail you have sent to us because it was a clerical error on my part and not an attempt to trespass upon the Westside Village portion of the Mar Vista Council boundaries.    And I would invite the President of the Mar Vista Neighborhood Council to realize our intentions as being a first step into creating a sense of community for Palms. 

I might add, it is quite coincidental that this is the 80th anniversary of the founding of the Mar Vista area, since it was exactly 40 years after the founding of The Palms, back in 1886.   Let's help make L.A. a better place to live by developing a common goal for our respective areas and continue to reach out to our communities to get more and more neighbors involved in our respective communities.

To all of this we respond:

How do we know that we Westside Villagers think of ourselves as being our "own community"? Has anybody asked us?
There are 12,000 residents in this area, after all. How many have been surveyed?

Have Mar Vista and the WV homeowners group ever responded favorably to the proposal that the city's Human Relations Commission foster just such a survey? Council member Bill Rosendahl has been trying to arrange a meeting "just to talk" since October 2005. Go here for details.

Who is dragging their feet in accepting the offer of the commission to mediate this dispute?

Well, it is the small group of homeowners who some four years ago forced all of us into the Mar Vista Community Council. And we mean small group — no more than 20 on the homeowners' Board of Directors.

(Mar Vista is the council where one of the hot topics of conversation these days is fixing up Venice Blvd. way over near Grand View Blvd.

(We wish the Mar Vistans well, but what does their fix-up project have to do with our Westside Village, our post office, our fire station, our Palms Middle School, our Palms-Westside Village Neighborhood Watch? Or our Trader Joe's — both of them.)

As for the so-called "boundaries" of Mar Vista, we have recently found yet another map that places our Village squarely within Palms. To all the maps listed in the S-U-P-E-R Web site, you can add a new one, this from the 2006 YELLOW BOOK recently distributed all over the Westside.

That blue
Palms marker on the map, straddling Military and Tilden north of Palms, has been put there by MapQuest based on Tele Atlas Data — two reputable companies that apparently can't agree that Westside Village is its "own community."

The Sun has always been open to printing any remarks by a Westside Village homeowners assn. or Mar Vista Community Council spokesperson to give their side of the issue. We have done so, in fact, with writings here in our former sister Web site, The Westmar Sun and here in December 2004 and here in September 2005 and here in December 2005 and here in March 2006, and also in April 2004 and February 2005. (We had to get the last one with a Freedom of Information request to the city.)

What's more, since we began posting in December 2004, we have always provided a link to the homeowners assn. Web site.

So, we await a cogent letter from the Other Side as to why we shouldn't get together with the Human Relations Commission to resolve this sticky community debate that has gone on way too long.

We'll be glad to post it. (We are still waiting.)

Statements by ROBERTA GOLAN SCHILLER, the only candidate for Zone 1 representative (Westside Village) on the Board of the Mar Vista Community Council.

The election will be held from 5 to 9 p.m. Monday, June 5, at Mar Vista Elementary School, 3330 Granville Blvd., in Mar Vista.

(The Sun recommends that Villagers NOT take part in this travesty, which is organized and operated by people not from our neighborhood.)

Schiller's official statement can be found on the MVCC Web site.
An e-mail from The Palms-Village Sun requested comments from candidate Roberta Schiller about the Mar Vista takeover of the Westside Village area

From: westmarsun-at-pacbell.net
Subject: Your candidacy in Zone 1 . . .
Date: May 27, 2006 7:58:28 PM PDT
To: Robertags-at-aol.com

Dear Roberta:

Congratulations on your becoming a candidate for the Zone 1 representative on the Mar Vista Community Council.

As you probably know, The Palms-Village Sun Web site covers Westside Village as well as the rest of Palms. We have 772 names on our mailing list, a sizable number of them being in Westside Village. At your request, I have not been sending you e-mail messages about the new stories on our site, but you can always find our latest offerings about Westside Village at 
http://www.palmsvillagesun.info/WV.current.html .

I have placed your statement about your candidacy (from the Mar Vista Community Council Web site) at http://www.palmsvillagesun.info/WV.current.html#schiller. [This has since been removed.]

Our readers, of course, are very much interested in your views on the petitions that have been circulating in the Village requesting that the pertinent city officials take "whatever steps are necessary" to help the Village form and then join with a combined Palms-Westside Village Neighborhood Council. There are now 275 signatures from Westside Village homeowners, renters and businesspeople.

As a member of the Board of the Westside Village Civic Assn. you must be aware of the reasons why the WVCA has not taken advantage of the offer of the City Human Relations Commission to help resolve the questions raised by these petitions. Just this month I asked for these reasons in an editorial titled "The Sun Has Always Been Open to Printing Any Remarks" at http://www.palmsvillagesun.info/WV.06.05.html#top.

I would be glad to post whatever statement you would like to offer concerning these petitions and in particular whether you feel it would or would not be a good idea to find out once and for all whether the 12,000 stakeholders in Zone 1 would like to merge with Palms or continue with Mar Vista.

On behalf of my readers (and your future constituents), I look forward to hearing from you.

Sincerely,

George Garrigues (11-year resident of Westside Village)
Editor and owner
The Palms-Village Sun

Unfortunately, the candidate did not see fit to reply to the question

From: Robertags-at-aol.com
Subject: Re: Your candidacy in Zone 1 . . .
Date: May 28, 2006 12:58:44 PM PDT
To: westmarsun-at-pacbell.net

George,
 
Thank you for your email and your congratulatory comments regarding my Zone 1 candidacy.  I see your signature includes your description as an "11-year resident of Westside Village" and I know of your dedication to our neighborhood.

I have lived in our Village for more than 30 years and have raised my family here.  Many of my neighborhood friends have been friends since my children were young.  We were on the PTA, at the Halloween Festivals and were room parents.  Some of these "children", now grown up, have come back to live in Westside Village because it has been such a terrific environment.  We are fortunate to have good schools that remain a real draw for young families moving to Westside Village.

As I mentioned in my candidacy statement, I worked in the Office of Mayor Riordan for about two years.  My position was to increase volunteerism in the City as well as to honor and acknowledge the volunteers through various City events.  It was about that time that the idea of Neighborhood Councils was formed.  I believe that the main purpose of NCs is to develop two-way communication with City government.  We all hear what our Councilmembers and Mayor are doing, but do they hear what we need?  In any case, it is my view that NCs work best when they are able to communicate the issues of the neighborhood in an organized and cogent manner.  Whether the Westside Village had joined with its neighbors to the north or to the south or west at the time of its formation, Westside Village is now a part of a very well-run and well-organized neighborhood council, MVCC, that represents its views and needs and provides a voice to City Government.

I recognize that you have a different opinion on this matter.  I hope that rather than focusing on our differences, you will see that the most important aspect to representation is our involvement in positive and meaningful answers to our community problems.  I am confident that Palms NC and MVCC -- as well as the other nearby councils -- will work together successfully. 

I have worked professionally in the area of non-profit management and volunteered on many Boards.  I am confident I will bring my experiences to this position and represent Zone 1 with integrity.  I thank you for your support, Roberta Schiller