Home Search News Arts & Culture Schools Real Estate
Opinion Letters Maps Feature article History Landmarks
Archives Photos Renters Westside Village Religion Citywide

WATCH FOR THE RETURN OF THE PALMS–VILLAGE SUN, IN MAY 2008

Our diversity is our strength

The Palms–Village Sun
News, opinion and features about Historic Palms,
including Westside Village
www.PalmsVillageSun.info
This site is not affiliated with any group. Opinions are those of the writers.

CITY DEMOLISHES OLD CHURCH, RIPS UP TREES FOR A $7.2 MILLION FIRE STATION AT THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF MOTOR AVE. AND REGENT ST.
At left you see what was there until late April 2005 — a condemned martial-arts center that previously was a Christian Science church. Full-grown trees and plantings were destroyed in the process.
The palms, cacti and other plantings were crunched with the rest of the building and carted off to an unknown fate. Beautiful aged trees facing Vinton Ave. (seen in the rear of the photo at top right) were the next to go.
Couldn't the city have saved the stately trees? (One of them is shown at the left.)
NOTHING IS PLANNED WHERE THE TREES WERE EXCEPT A PARKING LOT.
Sandbags line the fire station property to protect against flooding (or maybe to hold the fence up). (May 8, 2005)

We need straight reporting about fire station tree removal

One more time: Thank you for what you do to keep the neighborhood informed. You are an invaluable resource and do more to create community than most of the events the movers and shakers get up.

Sometimes I think people have trouble differentiating what you report as a reporter and what you opine as a resident. I generally assume that if it's opinion it must be yours, even if it isn't specifically labeled as such.

Case in point, the interesting news, and great pictures, of the new fire station project [at Regent and Motor]. I remember learning that most of these old fire stations [such as the present station on National at Vinton] were built as temporary buildings that have outlived their intended life spans by a good fifty years. I also remember at least one bond proposal for renovating them failed to pass the vote. Therefore, I'm grateful that a new facility, hopefully well suited to the task, is being built.

I totally agree with you about the trees, but isn't there a law that says that public works have to be built for the lowest price? To prevent malfeasance?

Moving trees is really expensive. Doing construction around trees is really expensive. My guess is that the price of such would have been deemed an inappropriate use of taxpayers' funds.

Do the Tree People provide aid in such a situation? Or some other agency? It doesn't do any good to rail at the removal of the trees without providing context and alternatives. A valid opinion, yes, it's a shame to cut down healthy trees. But making a lot of other people unhappy about the trees without providing more information isn't really useful, like the straight reporting portions of The Sun are.

JUDITH COHEN
June 19, 2005


Editor's note: This is a duplicate posting from our Letters page, here.